s-man23's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Gnome: Original]

Could have been better

Although I love the floyd when Barrett was still in the band, and thought this song was awesome, I really suggest you trip before you try to make artwork about tripping.
The flash had average graphics but in terms of artistic creativity.
The music quality seemed bad as well.

Everything is there but the insight

[Glurk!]

A great flash.

I remember a twilight zone episode like this. The one with the grandmother who finds tiny aliens in her attic, then it turns out at the end the aliens are actually earth men and the woman is a giant.

Loved this movie though. The graphics seemed a bit too loosley drawn and unfinished but it was still amazing, especially for a week's work!

jerbjpg responds:

thank you!

[Jewel:- Foolish Games]

Good but slow-paced

There was obviously some work put into this, which was a relief, but the movie was slow-moving. While you may have meant it to be this way, I personally don't think it worked. There wasn't much inspiration in this movie, at least I don't think so. The song in my opinion was lame and dead, and you didn't build much off of it, so the movie ended up being just that. Your art was good though, and it gave some relief from the slow-paced film.

[Psi-Arm Intro]

An awesome into, but not for the portal

This intro was seriously cool... But you can't post this here. I had to blam it... Previews go in the preview section. Movies go in the movies section. Can't wait to see the whole movie though.

[Event Flux]

wow.

I like random frame by frame, but it really has no point and therefore it's a little stupid. This movie was a perfect example of an amazing frame by frame animation- in the end it all came together. I gave you a ten for style because i loved the idea, it was really cool.

[AGE]

really good

Some amazing flash work here. The only problem with the silouhette type style that you have is things tend to be oddly animated, but it gives the flash more of an elegant feel instead of the sketchy feel of frame by frame freehand.
I really liked it though. By the way the birth part was great... reminded me of monty python, the meaning of life. good work, definitley an A.

[Robot Steal Brain]

...

the graphics were alright, but it could have used some animation. you definitley need to make the next one longer.
the music stopped playing when i hit replay.
the style like i said, needs animation

FreePablo responds:

IT'S CALLED A SHORT FILM.

[Borat: the chair!]

i didnt really get the joke,..

the graphics weren't great... 3.

the sound was good, sounds effects were good.

the style was kind of cool because the subtitles were so sycronized with the sound. I liked this a lot.

the humor was strictly what you made of it, but i thought the joke(s) were pretty dumb humor overall.

Gusto responds:

it is nais

[PICONJO Intro]

Cool, but

though Piconjo's intro was pretty cool, piconjo definitley needs to chill out on piconjo's ego. dude, you're making t-shirts with your name on them? come on, man. you may be good at flash, but... im douting anyone will put YOUR intro in front of THEIR movie, just because you, or even piconjo, asks them to.
nice intro though, i'd like to see one of your movies.

Piconjo responds:

Piconjo is not a Flash animator, Piconjo is the most awesome character ever to grace Newgrounds. He has already been booked on The Tonight show and The Late Show. There will be a biography in publication next week, check the book stores for it. There's talk of a big-budget Piconjo movie by Miramax that will be rated NC-17 from all the violence, sex, and dirty-dirty words.

[Mr. Kitty Cat, episode 1]

hahaha

that wasa funny as hell! improve the graphics, the sound was great. good job though.
in the futur dont use outlines too much like that, they don't look that great.